Almost everyone has been blamed for Alison’s murder, except for Emily. Emily is the “innocent one”. No one ever suspects her. But what if we should be? This is my theory that Emily killed Alison (and NOT on the -A team). Here’s what I dug up. 

#1 - Emily’s reaction. Look closely at these reactions. The first is Emily’s reaction to finding Alison’s body. The second is Emily’s reaction to finding Maya’s body? Notice a HUGE difference?? I did! She barely reacts to Alison’s death. Why? Alison was her BEST friend, and she was in love with her. She knew her for WAY longer than Maya. If anything, Emily looks….guilty in the first photo…..

 

#2 - In “The Perfect Storm” the first scene of Em is her rushing into her room and locking the door. She is covered head to toe in dirt, and then gets a text from -A saying “There’s only so much you can bury, Emily. You’re not done with me yet.”

At first we are led to believe that Emily trashed Alison’s memorial. But she says when she got there, it was already destroyed, and she grabbed the statues cause they were the only thing not broken. Hm…that seems weird. Why would she be covered head to toe in dirt if she just grabbed the statues? And what is Emily “burying”?

#3 - Emily’s motive. We all know that Alison was kinda a tease when it came to Emily. One moment she is kissing Emily in the library, the next she’s saying “What are you doing?! Just because we kissed in the library, doesn’t mean I’m into you like that.” and “Believe me, if I’m kissing you, it’s just practice for the real thing.”

#4 - The letter she wrote Alison. We all know Emily was hurt by Alison. She wrote Alison that letter….three days before she disappeared. Here’s a line from that letter “You’re not afraid of hurting me, so I wonder why I’m so afraid of hurting you.” Hmmm….

#5 - This scene really kinda struck me. It is the scene where Emily is spilling her guts to Dr. Sullivan. She says “I killed someone. Someone had a life. Someone was a living, breathing person.” 

What struck me about this was two things. One, she doesn’t say “I killed HIM. HE had a life. HE was a living, breathing person”. She uses a non-descript pronoun. 

Second, was the look on her face as she was saying this. It almost looks like she’s smiling a little…..

See what I mean?

#6 - Of course the flashback. Emily is under hypnotherapy, when she remembers the night Aly died. Emily is holding a shovel. Angry. And Alison is screaming. 

Later she says that she “mixed up the memories”. But that still means that she had some hidden memories of that night, right? The whole story just seemed suspicious….

Could Emily have snapped? Sick of all of Ali’s games she’s playing with her emotions?

Anything is possible in Rosewood (;

This was a theory sent to me by request! The theory that Maya was on the -A team. I am going to take that theory, and do my own version on it! Here it goes! 

#1 - The timing. Maya entered Emily’s life the same time -A did. Maya has been around since the pilot, where Emily got her first -A text. And who was the text about? MAYA. But it wasn’t even a text…..it was a note. A bit odd for -A, no? A handwritten note about Maya in Emily’s locker. Who goes to Emily’s school? Maya. 

#2 - The photos. Emily and Maya had that memorible make-out session in the photo booth. When they got out, the photos were conveniently missing. These photos later end up in the hands on Hanna, and Emily’s mom. Who wanted Emily to start being honest with herself, and to stop hiding? Maya. What a better way to do it than secretly slipping photos to everyone close to her. 

#3 - Maya had Alison’s stuff. In the pilot, we see a giant pile of Alison’s stuff on the curb. Maya said there was even more inside. Then in “Eye of the Beholder” Jason says that Maya dropped off MORE of Alison’s stuff; Maya was missing at the time, and Emily was surprised when Jason said it was from Maya. Mona somehow has her hands on a lot of Ali’s stuff (her diaries for example). Ever wonder how she got it? (;

#4 - True North. Maya was gone a LONG time at True North….but what happened while she was there? She ignores Emily most of the time there, and when Emily finally reaches her she says Maya sounds “distant”. Like she’s moved on. Hm that’s weird considering she was in love with her when she left, and she was in love with her when she came back. And Emily dated/liked Paige AND Samara during that time, making Maya jealous? Could Maya have been doing dirty -A team work during that time? It’s a perfect alibi, no? (; And many people found the lighter in the finale suspicious of referencing True North….

#5 - Maya Knew. Mona gave this infamous code to Hanna and Aria. “Miss Aria You’re A Killer Not Ezra’s Wife”, spelling “MAYA KNEW”. What did Maya know? Some people are saying she “knew about Nate coming to Rosewood”. What?? Mona gave them everything they needed to figure that out with the website! So what did Maya know? Perhaps about the inner workings of the -A team?

#6 - Maya’s bedroom. In the pilot, Spencer sees a blonde in Alison’s bedroom. Of course we are supposed to believe it is Alison, but Maya had already moved in at that point. What if this was the first sighting on the infamous blonde wig?

#7 - Maya’s suspicious friendships. We know Maya had a “texting relationship” with Noel. Garrett picked her up the night she died, but didn’t kill her. She was seen suspiciously talking to Jason, but we never found out about what. And she apparently hung out with Holden as well. None of these relationships were ever really explained.

#8 - Maya’s secrets. Going off the last theory….how come we never knew Maya was going to the Kahn parties? She was dating Emily at the time. And what is she hiding with Jason? And how did she end up crashing at Noels? Why so many secrets Maya?

#9 - The videos on the website. Ok so Nate was obviously a crazy stalker. But why wouldn’t Maya go to the police? Maya only said that she was afraid of someone on the videos on her site, not that it was Nate. Could she have been afraid of the -A team?

What if Maya was on the -A Team all along. Recruited to get close to Emily (much like Toby and Spencer). But when she fell in love with Emily, she wanted to leave the -A Team. That’s when she tried to run away to San Francisco, and the -A team killed her before she could leave.

What do you think!?!? xo

I know guys, I hate writing this theory :( So as well all know, Marlene King directed the “previously on” on the finale, and said it was “a present for us”. Why? Because it was awesome?? Or because there were clues in it?

So here is the gift she gave us (: 

Here is what I noticed from the montage….

#1 - Caleb kissing Hanna. All these scenes are like terrible terrible things that have happened to the girls…..then there is a very quick frame of Hanna and Caleb in the alley way in 3x09. So…..why is this included? It was obviously added to the montage for a reason. But why a scene where NOTHING bad happened….? WEIRD, RIGHT?!?!?! 

#2 - Caleb again. But again, why this scene? Sure it was an intense moment. But nothing compared to the elevator dropping, or Spencer finding Toby dead, or trying to be pushed off a train….

#3 - Caleb AGAIN! Obviously this was a terrible moment in the show. But could it also be foreshadowing? This is the THIRD clip in the montage of Caleb. Seems a little weird to me. There’s more clips of  him than of the liars. 

Then there was an interview with one of the PLL writers, where this was said…

Plus, many of the characters have been confirmed for Season 4….Caleb is not one of them..yet….

Last we saw Caleb he ran off to go find his dad. We all know what happens when people disappear on the show…

The montage was very Caleb focused…..season 4 is very Hanna focused…..oh no guys :( I really really hope this theory isn’t true!